-
Step 1: Confirm what they actually manufacture (not what they resell)
-
Step 2: Get the photometric file, not just the spec sheet
-
Step 3: Verify certification scope (this is the step most buyers skip)
-
Step 4: Ask for the last three references — and call them
-
Step 5: Compare lead times against three months of history
-
Step 6: Ask what they're NOT good at
-
Step 7: Run a same-spec quote comparison (not a same-price comparison)
-
Common mistakes to avoid
I handle lighting procurement for a mid-sized electrical distributor. Been doing it since 2016. In that time, I've placed orders with 40+ manufacturers and gotten burned by four of them badly enough that it still stings. Two of those mistakes cost us over $14,000 combined and one nearly ended a client relationship.
This checklist is what I run every new manufacturer through now. Seven steps. Takes about 90 minutes per vendor if you do it properly. Use it whenever you're evaluating a new supplier for LED high bays, area lights, emergency fixtures, or OEM work.
It's not glamorous. It's just the stuff I wish someone had handed me in 2016.
Step 1: Confirm what they actually manufacture (not what they resell)
Half the "manufacturers" you'll find on Google are trading companies. They don't have a factory. They buy from someone who does, slap a logo on it, and quote you a price.
That's not always disqualifying — but you need to know which one you're dealing with.
What to ask:
- "Which SKUs come off your own line versus a partner factory?"
- "Can I see the production facility?" (video call is fine)
- "Who manufactures your [specific product] — you or a contract partner?"
If they can't answer quickly, that's your answer.
Here's the thing though — generalists and specialists both exist, and you want to match the vendor to the job. If I need Dialight LED high bay replacements, I'm calling someone who lives and breathes that product category. If I need a custom area light OEM run, I want a factory that does OEM work as their default mode, not their side hustle.
I once ordered 60 area lights from a vendor who "also did" OEM work. Lead time slipped from 4 weeks to 11. When I asked why, they admitted the OEM line was new. Would've been fine if they'd just told me upfront.
Step 2: Get the photometric file, not just the spec sheet
A spec sheet tells you what the marketing team wants you to believe. An IES file tells you what the fixture actually does.
If a supplier can't send you a .ies file for a specific model — with the exact optics and driver you're buying — walk away. That's not negotiable for commercial or industrial work.
Why this matters: I've seen two fixtures with identical wattage and "20,000 lumens" on the label deliver visibly different results on-site. Different distribution. Different glare. One was genuinely usable, the other we had to re-spec.
When I compared the two fixtures side by side in DIALux — same wattage, same lumens claim — I finally understood why the photometric file is the single most important document in this industry.
Checkpoint: Open the .ies file. Confirm the model number matches the quote. Confirm the beam angle matches what you need. Don't skip this because it feels technical.
Step 3: Verify certification scope (this is the step most buyers skip)
Everyone asks "Are you UL listed?" Almost nobody asks "UL listed for what, specifically?"
Certifications apply to specific models, specific configurations, specific environments. A manufacturer can be UL-listed for their indoor linear fixtures and not for their explosion-proof line. They can have a DLC listing that covers one wattage but not the one you're ordering.
- Ask for the UL file number and look it up.
- Ask which specific SKUs are covered by the DLC listing they're claiming.
- For hazardous location products, confirm the class and division rating matches your site — not just that they "have explosion-proof."
This is the one where I'll admit I got lucky, not smart. A supplier quoted us on a fixture rated for Class I Division 2. Our client's site was Division 1. We caught it during a site walkthrough, not during procurement. That would've been a $30k+ redo plus a safety incident report.
Lucky. Not smart. Now I check.
Step 4: Ask for the last three references — and call them
Every manufacturer has happy customers. Some of those "happy customers" are actually the manufacturer's cousin.
How to do this properly:
- Ask for three references from orders placed in the last 12 months.
- Ask that at least one is for the specific product line you're buying.
- Call them. All three. Yes, this takes time.
Questions to actually ask the references (not the softballs):
- "What went wrong on your order?" (everyone has something — if they say "nothing," they're not being honest)
- "How did the manufacturer handle the problem?"
- "Would you order from them again at the same price?"
- "What do you wish you'd asked before ordering?"
That last question is worth more than the other three combined.
Step 5: Compare lead times against three months of history
Anyone can promise a 3-week lead time. The question is whether they've hit it.
Ask: "What was your on-time delivery rate for the last 90 days, and how do you measure it?"
If they can't answer with a number, they don't measure it. If they don't measure it, they don't manage it.
I don't need 100%. Nobody hits 100%. 92-95% is solid for a first-year relationship. Below 85% and you're going to be the one explaining delays to your client.
Step 6: Ask what they're NOT good at
This is the step that separates the vendors I trust from the ones I don't.
Push hard here. "We're strong across the board" is a red flag, not a selling point. A vendor who says "high bays and area lights, yes — but for hazardous location work, you should talk to a specialist" just earned my trust for everything else.
The vendor who said "this isn't our strength — here's who does it better" earned my business on the next four orders without me even asking for a quote comparison.
Look, I'd rather work with a specialist who knows their limits than a generalist who overpromises. Anybody claiming to be an equally good emergency light supplier AND LED high bay manufacturer AND custom OEM shop is either lying or doing all three with average quality and worse support.
Verify the boundary claim, though. If they say they don't do explosion-proof, and you later find out they do but quietly — that's a different problem.
Step 7: Run a same-spec quote comparison (not a same-price comparison)
The cheapest quote almost never wins in lighting, because it's never actually the same product.
Build a spec sheet first. Force every vendor to quote against it. Then compare.
Common places where "cheap" quotes hide the difference:
- Driver brand (Meanwell vs. generic — big deal on lifespan)
- Heatsink material and weight
- LED chip brand and bin code
- Warranty terms (10-year "limited" usually means very specifically limited)
- Whether the quote includes shipping, tariffs, or a spare-parts allocation
I built this comparison after the third time we ordered "the same fixture" from two vendors and got two visibly different products. The first one I chalked up to a fluke. The second one I blamed on the vendor. The third one I built a spreadsheet. (Should have been step one.)
Now I never quote without a spec sheet in hand.
Common mistakes to avoid
Mistaking a low quote for a good deal. The $200 fixture that fails in 18 months costs more than the $340 fixture that lasts 10 years — especially when you factor in the labor for the swap-out.
Trusting a rep promise over the paperwork. If it's not in writing (spec sheet, cert file, quote terms), it doesn't exist.
Ordering from a new vendor without a small first order. Yes, the volume discount is tempting. Order 10 units first. Live through one delivery cycle. Then scale.
Skipping the reference calls because "they're a big brand." Size doesn't protect you from a bad batch or a distracted rep. Ask the questions anyway.
Assuming OEM means custom engineering. Sometimes "area light OEM" just means they'll sticker their standard fixture with your logo. Clarify which one you're getting before signing.
Run the full checklist once per manufacturer. Update it once a year. It's saved us more than the cost of implementing it — and honestly, it's saved me more embarrassment than dollars at this point.
Prices and lead-time benchmarks in this article are based on our own purchasing records through Q4 2024. Verify current pricing and terms directly with any vendor before committing.